Copying Is Fashionable

Author:Mr Carlos Magnanini
Profession:Clarke, Modet & Co

There are few things as ephemeral as fashion. Collections are seasonal so they last just for the season: Autumn-Winter and Spring-Summer. In the case of counterfeiters, however, time has never been a restriction. Six months are sufficient to counterfeit, manufacture and commercialize goods.

Some attribute those imitations to the fact that the fashion industry reflects trends. Thus, it wouldn't be surprising if different catwalks staged similar designs. It is also commonly believed that fashion stands for inspiration and its effects should not be deemed as imitations but as mutual "influences". Finally, pragmatists acknowledge imitation as a resource to make available an haute couture design for mass consumption. Yet, the truth is that imitation is a fact.

In this sense, should fashion designs be registered as intellectual property? Protection arises upon creation. Consequently, registration requirements seem not to be necessary in order to enjoy protection. However, the deposit provides for presumption in case proof of authorship is to be established.

The Argentine law that sets forth Copyright protection is Law No 11,723, passed in 1933. Even though said law was subsequently amended and it has been supplemented with several regulatory decrees, the law in itself has been sufficiently suitable, adapting to changes and withstanding the test of time.

The bottom line is to emphasize that copyright protects formal creations, i.e. protection does not apply for ideas, processes, methods and concepts per se. For instance, concepts such as the miniskirt —a short skirt extending up to the mid-thigh— or the bikini — a two-piece bathing suit—, would not have been admitted for registration unless registration takes the form of material expression, videlicet, "a short skirt, bell-shaped, made of a black and white horizontally striped silk...." Accordingly, for valid protection, the elements contained in the work, including pictures and drawings attached to the description, must be fully characterized.

The registration process must be fulfilled before the National Directorate for Copyright, which has decentralized the reception of works deposits into different "collaborating agencies", namely, Boards and Organizations pertaining to each industry. Application forms requirements and fees vary based on whether the work has not been released or otherwise, it has been made available, i.e., if it is a published work, in which case, fees will be...

To continue reading